How to Evaluate Third-Party Investment Managers for Insurer Portfolios

Insurers appoint external investment managers to access specialist expertise, broader markets, stronger analytical tools, or additional capacity during periods of organisational change. The decision, however, is much bigger than comparing historic returns. An appointed manager becomes part of the insurer’s operating model, risk framework, reporting chain, and regulatory environment.

A sound assessment considers whether the manager can protect capital, generate appropriate risk-adjusted returns, support liquidity needs, and communicate clearly when markets become unsettled. For Australian insurers, this also means considering APRA expectations, IFRS 17 reporting, foreign-exchange exposure, climate-related risks, and the practical realities of managing assets across Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, and offshore markets.

Define The Mandate Before Reviewing Managers

The first step is to define what the insurer actually needs the external manager to do. A mandate might cover Australian fixed interest, global credit, infrastructure, equities, private markets, cash, or a multi-asset portfolio. Each asset class requires different skills, controls, liquidity assumptions, benchmarks, and performance measures.

The mandate should specify the portfolio’s purpose within the insurance balance sheet. A claims-paying portfolio may prioritise duration matching and high-quality liquidity, while a shareholder portfolio may accept greater volatility in pursuit of long-term growth. The investment objective should connect directly with liabilities, solvency targets, capital requirements, tax considerations, and the insurer’s risk appetite statement.

Insurers should also document the decisions that remain in-house. These may include strategic asset allocation, currency hedging, responsible investment exclusions, liquidity reserves, and the authority to change risk limits. When responsibilities are vague, accountability becomes difficult to establish after a loss or a breach.

A useful reference point for governance teams is the broader exchange of ideas found through regional governance discussions, particularly when assessing cross-border responsibilities, legal arrangements, and oversight of providers operating across Asia-Pacific markets.

Assess Portfolio Fit And Investment Philosophy

A manager’s philosophy should be clear enough to explain in plain English and specific enough to test through evidence. Statements about being “fundamental”, “long term”, or “risk aware” have limited value unless the manager can show how those principles influence security selection, portfolio construction, trading, and sell decisions.

The insurer should examine how the manager handles the relationship between return and liability risk. For a life insurer, interest-rate sensitivity, credit migration, and asset-liability duration may matter more than a peer-relative equity ranking. For a general insurer, liquidity and capital preservation may become critical after severe weather events increase claims. Australian portfolios may also need to account for concentrated exposure to domestic banks, miners, property markets, and the Australian dollar.

Review actual portfolios rather than relying on model examples. Ask for holdings-based analysis across normal and stressed periods, including the Global Financial Crisis, the early pandemic shock, rapid interest-rate rises, and major credit events. A manager should explain where performance came from, which risks were intentional, and which exposures were accidental.

The assessment should include portfolio overlap with existing mandates. Two managers may appear diversified by strategy name while holding similar issuers, sectors, currencies, or private assets. Look-through analysis is essential when the insurer uses pooled funds, derivatives, external sub-managers, or structured investments.

Examine Risk Management And Liquidity

Risk management needs to operate at portfolio, firm, and group levels. Evaluate market-risk limits, counterparty controls, concentration thresholds, issuer-quality rules, derivatives governance, collateral processes, and escalation procedures. Policies are useful, yet the quality of implementation matters more than the document itself.

Request examples of breaches and near misses. The manager should explain how an issue was identified, who received the alert, how quickly the position was corrected, and what changed afterwards. A firm that claims to have had no incidents may be offering an incomplete picture, since credible control environments measure and report small exceptions before they become material events.

Liquidity deserves particular attention for insurers. A portfolio may need to fund claims, collateral calls, tax payments, redemptions, or reinsurance obligations at short notice. Private debt, infrastructure, property, and less-traded credit can generate attractive returns but may be difficult to sell during a stressed market. Assess liquidity under a severe but plausible scenario rather than relying on average daily turnover.

Australian insurers should include catastrophe and regional stress assumptions in this review. Bushfires, floods, cyclones affecting northern Queensland, and storms along the New South Wales coast can create claims pressure at the same time that markets are volatile. The manager’s liquidity plan should show how it would support the insurer during such a period.

Review People, Operations And Technology

Investment capability is closely tied to the people responsible for decisions. Review the experience, tenure, responsibilities, succession arrangements, and incentive structures of the proposed team. Identify who has authority to override a model, approve an exception, change a valuation, or reduce a position when conditions move quickly.

High staff turnover can weaken institutional knowledge, especially in credit, private markets, and complex derivatives. Ask for turnover statistics over several years and investigate departures among senior decision-makers, risk officers, technology leaders, and relationship managers. A polished presentation from a new team should not be treated as evidence of an established process.

Operational due diligence should cover trade execution, settlement, reconciliations, pricing, corporate actions, cash management, tax reporting, and records retention. The insurer should understand which functions are internal, outsourced, or dependent on a fourth party. Confirm that service providers have tested business continuity plans and recovery arrangements.

Technology reviews should address cybersecurity, access controls, data lineage, incident response, model governance, and integration with the insurer’s systems. Data that arrives late, lacks meaningful metadata, or cannot be reconciled to the custodian creates avoidable pressure for finance and investment operations teams.

Analyse Performance, Fees And Reporting

Performance should be assessed against the correct benchmark, risk budget, and investment horizon. A manager who beats a broad market index may still fail to meet the insurer’s mandate if the portfolio carries excessive duration, credit, currency, or liquidity risk. Compare gross and net returns, drawdowns, volatility, information ratios, downside capture, and performance attribution.

Look at results across complete market cycles and distinguish skill from market beta. A credit manager may benefit from falling spreads, while an equity manager may simply hold more technology stocks than the benchmark. Attribution should reveal the contribution from asset allocation, security selection, currency, duration, sector positioning, leverage, and fees.

Fees should be reviewed against the complexity and capacity of the strategy. Assess management fees, performance fees, transaction costs, custody charges, research expenses, foreign-exchange spreads, administration costs, and fees charged by underlying vehicles. Private-market mandates require particular care around valuation, commitment structures, management fees on committed capital, and exit costs.

Reporting must support both investment decisions and statutory responsibilities. Australian insurers may need information that aligns with APRA reporting, AASB requirements, IFRS 17 processes, tax reporting, and internal capital analysis. Before appointment, test sample reports for accuracy, timeliness, transparency, and compatibility with the insurer’s data architecture. The IASA Conference programme can also help finance and accounting professionals track current thinking on insurance reporting, technology, and investment operations.

Conduct Legal, Regulatory And Responsible Investment Due Diligence

Legal due diligence should establish the investment vehicle, governing law, custody model, termination rights, indemnities, liability standards, valuation provisions, and treatment of errors. The insurer should know precisely what happens if the manager breaches a limit, becomes insolvent, loses a key licence, or relies on a failed service provider.

For an Australian appointment, confirm the manager’s relevant Australian Financial Services Licence position, licensing exemptions, regulatory status, and arrangements for dealing with ASIC and APRA-regulated clients. Where the manager is offshore, document how Australian law, local regulation, tax, custody, and enforcement interact. A familiar brand does not remove the need for legal review.

Responsible investment claims should be tested with the same discipline as performance claims. Review voting records, engagement outcomes, escalation processes, climate-risk analysis, modern slavery controls, and the treatment of controversial sectors. An insurer should understand whether environmental, social, and governance factors are financially material inputs, exclusion screens, marketing language, or a combination of these.

Climate analysis needs to reflect local exposures. Australian property, infrastructure, agriculture, and utilities may face different physical and transition risks from assets in Europe or North America. Ask how scenarios affect valuations, cash flows, credit quality, insurance costs, and liquidity. The manager should provide evidence of decision-useful analysis rather than broad statements about sustainability.

Build An Ongoing Oversight Model

Appointment is the beginning of the relationship, not the end of the evaluation. Establish a review calendar covering performance, risk, liquidity, compliance, personnel, operations, cyber controls, responsible investment, and business continuity. The frequency should reflect the mandate: a complex private-credit portfolio requires different monitoring from a simple cash mandate.

Define escalation triggers in advance. These might include a material performance deviation, key-person departure, repeated guideline breaches, valuation uncertainty, significant litigation, ownership change, credit deterioration, or a cyber incident. The insurer should know who can place a manager on watch, restrict cash flows, require remediation, or terminate the appointment.

Governance meetings should encourage clear discussion rather than passive receipt of reports. Invite the manager to explain what has changed in the portfolio, where uncertainty has increased, and which assumptions may no longer hold. Comparing the manager’s view with the insurer’s internal risk, actuarial, finance, and claims perspectives often reveals issues that a standard quarterly pack will miss.

Industry events can strengthen this oversight capability by bringing investment, finance, technology, and operations perspectives into the same conversation. The IASA community provides a relevant setting for Australian professionals to examine emerging practices, meet solution providers, and discuss how investment governance connects with wider insurance operations.

Practical Selection And Oversight Recommendations

A disciplined process produces better decisions when the evaluation criteria are agreed before presentations begin. It should give equal weight to investment capability, operational reliability, transparency, cultural fit, and the manager’s ability to work within an insurer’s governance framework.

Use a documented scorecard and retain the evidence behind each rating. This supports committee decisions, makes trade-offs visible, and reduces the risk that a persuasive presentation or recent performance result dominates the appointment process.

The strongest external manager is not necessarily the one with the highest recent return. It is the one whose strategy suits the insurer’s liabilities, whose controls can withstand scrutiny, whose data arrives in a usable form, and whose people communicate honestly when conditions deteriorate.

Investment committees, finance leaders, risk teams, and operations executives can use this framework to structure a formal review, challenge shortlisted managers, and create an oversight model that lasts beyond the appointment date. A thorough assessment protects the portfolio while making the manager a dependable extension of the insurer’s broader business.